Palash Biswas On Unique Identity No1.mpg

Unique Identity No2

Please send the LINK to your Addresslist and send me every update, event, development,documents and FEEDBACK . just mail to palashbiswaskl@gmail.com

Website templates

Zia clarifies his timing of declaration of independence

What Mujib Said

Jyoti basu is DEAD

Jyoti Basu: The pragmatist

Dr.B.R. Ambedkar

Memories of Another Day

Memories of Another Day
While my Parents Pulin Babu and basanti Devi were living

"The Day India Burned"--A Documentary On Partition Part-1/9

Partition

Partition of India - refugees displaced by the partition

Sunday, March 1, 2015

Budget for CORPORATE Global!

Mar 01 2015 : The Economic Times (Mumbai)
Budget for Growth, Competitiveness


It's bold, growth-oriented and inclusive. That about sums up the reaction of industry and market to FM Arun Jaitley's second Budget which has taken care of almost all segments -business, education, health, senior citizens and youth.
Check out what economists, analysts, corporate honchos and market mavens have to say about the Union Budget
Raamdeo Agrawal:

It is a very good Budget in the sense that for the first time I get the feeling that the Finance Minister is listening to the people's suggestions and the problems they're facing. One of the biggest points is that an investment management facility has been allowed--to bring investment management from Hong Kong and Singapore to India. And we will finally have an international finance centre, the GIFT City in Ahmedabad. This is a huge development.

Apart from this, there is the promise of corporate tax deduction from 30% to 25%. This is a five-year promise, and it is not yet known how much will be cut this year. But a five-year possibility is also a huge thing. The SARFAESI (The Securitization and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest) Act has been extended to all NBFCs--this gives them a lot of teeth. And overall tax mobilisation is limited. So the burden is little and there is an allround push for growth. I thought the infra-spend push was not big enough, but we need to see the final points.

Swaminathan Aiyar:

It is a first-class Budget. I have a few reservations, but nevertheless this is a Budget for growth. Even more important, it is a Budget for global competitiveness to put India right out there. I am very happy to see that there is a push to cut red tape to increase ease of doing business. At the same time, I am glad to see that a considerable amount shows that this is not a Budget just for fat-cat corporates. There is a huge amount for every section of society, including the poor.

Just some caveats--I find that the service tax is up to 14% and excise 12.5%. I thought we were going for a unified GST, so I do not understand why those two figures have gone apart. I want to add that on fiscal deficit, I am disappointed he did not stick to his word. Having made the commitment last time, he should have done it.

I am further disappointed that the revenue deficit is as high as 2.8%, which means the quality of the fiscal is not as good as it should be. Finally, all this data presumes a growth of 8-8.5%, about which there have been questions. If you have a failure at this end, there will be other problems.But, taken on face value, I would say he has done a good job overall.

ET NOW:

Do you think the biggest hurrah is purely on the corporate tax side, because if corporate tax rates go down, EPS will automatically move up?

Raamdeo Agrawal:

Yes, eventually it will move up. The clarity is not there about current years. Service tax going up from 12% to 14% is real. One has to see what is the total impact of the infra-growth push, infra-spend push, and of course the additional Rs 70-80 thousand crore. But apart from this, 3%, 4%, 5% of GDP coming from extra budget resource and such does not seem to be coming through. So there is some kind of disappointment, but we need to see the final footprints.

ET NOW:

Plenty of things as far as the financial sector is concerned. The FII, FDI, the FMC merger--fair amount of changes that will allow capital flow and the gold monetisation scheme. Give us your overall sense of the budget.

Punita Kumar Sinha:

It was a very pleasant surprise that he has balanced the needs of all segments of the economy, rather than the super rich--who are the only ones to be impacted a bit negatively. The corporate sector, the rural sector, the thrust on education, health, senior citizens, youth--there are just so many segments of the economy that are going to benefit. Therefore, I would call this a growth-oriented budget and long-term the trend is to simplify the tax structure, which will make it easier to do business in India. It is going to help domestic investors and foreign investors.

ET NOW:

Like everybody has been saying, it is a balanced budget. He (Jaitley) has spoken to corporate India, he has also taken care of the middle class. There is a plenty of push as far as social-sector schemes are concerned. Do you believe it is a balanced budget?

Mythili Bhusnurmath:

I differ a little bit from Swami. It is definitely a pro-growth Budget, but through the corporate route. So, it is pro-business and pro-overseas investors. I am not sure that much has been really done for the poor. The hope really is that the public investment that the government is driving will help the lower classes.But there are many things-(such as) making EPF optional--that goes against the interest of the poor. Despite the list of schemes for the poor, they have really not been taken care off as much as a government that claims to be doing so should.

ET NOW:

Swami has given a thumbs-up to the Budget. Markets believe it is a good Budget. What is your assessment? Do you believe it is a progrowth Budget?

Chanda Kochhar:

Yes, it is actually a very good Budget because there is a fine balance between growth, inclusiveness and fiscal discipline.So, it is definitely pro-growth and, at the same time, it takes into account fiscal prudence as well as inclusiveness. A very important thing to say is that let us kickstart investment through the public sector units that is a very very good beginning and a very pragmatic way of looking at it. Then, of course, increasing the devolution towards the States but, over and above that, a lot of enabling things like the entire plug and play model. The entire relook at the PPP model and of course the dispute resolution and so on, the stage has been set for a much larger growth in infrastructure.

ET NOW:

What is the most defining part of this year's Budget and has the Budget done enough to kick start the stalled growth? Manish Chokhani:

Well, if you think of the Budget as a continuum and how this government has been redesigning the whole architecture of India, we are moving away from a command and control society to something where you are putting power back into the hand of the average citizen and the States. So, if you think of the way they have gone about it, they have already done the Jan Dhan Yojna and the direct benefits transfer which creates power back into the hands of the citizen rather than someone subsidising you and then you are going out and buying goods at a subsided price. You are now pro-choice. Similarly, you have devolved power back from the Centre to the States. So, they can decide how they want to go ahead. So, what were the big things one was looking for in this Budget was, directionally, where is this country going. So, you are in a way overturning the whole architecture of India away from the sort of Soviet or British imperialistic system, which we used to have, towards a more participative kind of Republican or Conservative society, which is directionally the right way to go. They have adhered to the path of fiscal prudence. They are giving more tax benefits a way to citizens as well as corporate sector. They are investing more into infrastructure. So, while the headline numbers may not look like, they have changed, the proof of the pudding is in the fact that you are shifting from 80% revenue and 20% capex to incrementally going in the other direction where over the next three or four years you will end up doing 80% capex, 20% revenue and in some sense rebuild the whole country. Also, putting this social security net across various strata of society and also providing means for people to, like I said, exercise their own choice gives you a completely new architecture and a fillip to growth. So, we are tremendously excited about it.

ET NOW:

The consensus view is that this is a growth budget. Are you okay with the fact that they have slipped on the fisc; they have allowed themselves a little bit more leeway to meet fiscal deficit targets. Is that okay with you?

Sunil Kant Munjal:

Actually, we had recommended this. We said considering that you need to increase public expenditure, current position allows you some headroom with lower oil prices and lower inflation but may not be enough for the amount that you need to infuse because for the private sector investment to come in, he is taking longer than we had expected. The consumption has not picked up as quickly as we had expected.So, there was a need for public expenditure to come in. So, we are okay with this. Overall, he has done something interesting. It is like a workman's budget. He had touched many many small areas but at the same time he has made a few very dramatic changes ­ things like introducing the bankruptcy law, things like overall looking at the restructuring of the public sector banks itself. I am not sure how many of you noticed. It slipped in very quietly but this is a transition ­ creating independent public sector banks ­ which would give them much more freedom to operate. So, there are two or three on the financial sector system, there are some pretty interesting recommendations there ­ simplification of taking wealth tax away but not losing the revenue, he is adding that 2% to income tax, etc. But overall, it is a well designed budget especially considering where we are right now and where we need to get to.

ET NOW:

FM has set up a new infra fund. He is talking about additional `70,000 crore being spent; he is talking about new bonds; he has spoken about rebalancing the PPP model. It was also announced in the previous Budget, the 3P India.Nothing really took off there.

GV Sanjay Reddy:

I am very optimistic because there are many things that he spoke about in infrastructure. I tried to count, he used the word more than 30 times. But, the most important thing is, the focus is given, the maximum focus, on infrastructure. A simple thing like even talking about PPP, the recognition that government has to take the maximum amount of risk, the rebalancing of risk is a critical recognition that needs to be done. Obviously, that cannot be done through a budget. It has to be done through a more detailed programme over the rest of the year. The amount of investment that they are talking about, even the fiscal deficit, I am perfectly fine with making it instead of two years, making it a three-year target but if it goes into the right sectors, the increase in expenditure. You know even a simple thing like fund managers who just stay away from India, these are all small things but they make a big impact especially for foreign investment.

ET NOW:

Corporate tax cut is something that India Inc is going to welcome the road map of a cut and he is going to withdraw some exemptions as well.Is that a welcome move?

Swaminathan Aiyar:

The Budget certainly spells out an additionality that there is going to be that much more public investment. This will definitely help but beyond that point, the big question is will we really be doing 8-8.5% growth? If we do not get that real growth, then I am afraid you are not going to get the revenues which the government is going to invest. You have to cross your fingers and hope that this high-growth rate is for real. If that is not the case, a number of the other calculations will come tumbling down.But taking the figures at face value yes this is a Budget for growth. It should be able to kickstart the process, not just directly. I would say this will animate spirits.

ET NOW:

How do you read the whole host of tax proposals in the Budget? The move to cut corporate tax over a four-year period, the move to hike service tax and also the move towards easing tax litigation?

Parthasarathi Shome:

I must say that I am duly impressed by the tax proposals. The preannouncement of the reduction in corporate tax over four years is an excellent idea, that many countries already follow. Now that the finance minister has taken the step to do the same, businesses can plan much better. Second, in terms of the service tax, it had to be done at some point and he has bitten the bullet there. At the same time, the surcharge on the super rich was also called for. It now compares somewhat in terms of other countries like South Africa and developed countries where at this one-crore point their marginal rates are much higher. So all in all, I would say that in the overall direction, it has been very impressive on the tax front.

However, when you go into the nitty-gritty, he will have to follow up on some of the issues. He said that on the indirect transfers issue, there will be a circular brought out by the CBDT. It has taken a long time and they must follow this up very quickly. I am very glad that on GAAR, he has given a two-year reprieve for implementation but the most important thing is for proper training of the tax officials in order to carry their duty out.

ET NOW:

PM promised that he will work towards reducing the ease of doing business. Do you see enough in terms of detailing in the budget that will address this big concern of corporate India to improve the ease of doing business?

Chanda Kochhar:

Yes, not reduce but improve ease of doing business. Clearly this point has been touched upon in various forms. First off all when you talk of the plug and play model that itself goes to say that we will create a project ready and then hand it over for investment. Then you heard about the ebiz portal where all the approvals can be kind of combined and they could be tracked on an electronic basis. Then you had the reference to the fact that you can actually start business without prior approvals and then actually get regulated thereafter that is again a very very important point towards ease of doing business. Also, there are some important points which in a way combined not just ease of doing business but enhance business in India, for example this whole permanent establishment tax on the funds.

ET NOW:

What do you think is the big idea from this budget, ultimately markets want earnings, do you think the budget has done enough to aid earnings going forward?

Shankar Sharma: The move on corporate tax is something that I personally have believed that India in light of what happened after 2008, we definitely needed to cut corporate taxes to spur investment and I am very, very, very pleased to see this move and we do business in the UK and now UK corporate taxes are something like 20% down from north of 30% when we started doing business there 10-15 years back. So for a lot of our international transactions now, we actually choose the UK as a jurisdiction rather than go to jurisdiction where you might not have any tax but they are not supposed to be very, very legitimate jurisdiction so you can see how much investment flows back into the UK simply because they cut taxes. I hope this 25% over four years actually happens and I am pretty sure when the happen, you will find a lot of investment coming into India to take advantage of this low tax rate.

ET NOW:

Everyone on our panel seem to be applauding the Budget. So let us find some fault lines and if you cannot find one, let me give you a hint ­ tax free bonds, which is bad news for the SIP and equity investors.

Sunil Singhania:

Frankly, from my perspective, the event is behind us. We make a lot about an event and the finance minister has clearly said that it is not only in the Budget, but in the next three, four, five years that they will keep on taking steps. So, we are very positive on the economy and the markets. The Budget was an important document and it is behind us now. Let us focus on what the positives can be and very clearly, both the microeconomic and the government support is there for the economy. As long as returns are made, we are not bothered about investors. The investors are smart enough to find their way into assets, which will give them good returns.

ET NOW:

Are you happy with what you have seen?
As far as the infrastructure thrust is concerned, plenty of proposals in the sector. One the interest thrust is the plug-and-play, other, the increase in allocation. What excites you the most?

Vinayak Chatterjee:

Actually, a slew of measures announced should certainly excite the infrastructure sector. We see it as an extremely positive Budget for us. Let me outline what our observations of the boosters for the infrastructure sector are: First, it is a very clear recognition of the role of public expenditure in infrastructure projects and the vehicle to kick-start the growth cycle that we had discussed before the Budget and we see it has been significantly re-emphasised by the FM. Point number two is just before the Budget, we were discussing that we have been advocating creation of budget vehicles to garner fronts from different sources and he announced the creation of a national infrastructure and investment fund, with an initial seed capital of `20,000 crore from the Consolidated Fund of India. We would say thank you, and well done. Point number three, tax-free bonds to garner resources outside the Consolidated Fund of India for roads, rail and irrigation is a very good step. Point number four is PPP revisited. Five, corporatisation of the 12 major ports owned by the government.

Point number six. After 10 years of speaking to the government, from PMO to planning commission, we have got the point across to the government that projects should be awarded transparently only if all permissions are in place, which is something the FM said will be the norm. To conclude, we really could not have expected more from the Budget.













Sexy SENSEX

imggallery

Shot in the Arm for Infra   Thrust on rural & urban spending , tilt towards capital expenditure, regulation of NBFCs , drawing up of a 3-5-year broad blueprint for turning around the economy and better clarity on implementation could spur the `Make in India' initiative

Shot in the Arm for Infra


Thrust on rural & urban spending , tilt towards capital expenditure, regulation of NBFCs , drawing up of a 3-5-year broad blueprint for turning around the economy and better clarity on implementation could spur the `Make in India' initiative





KEEP THE CHANGE C RANGARAJAN FORMER GOVERNOR, RBI   A BEGINNING Dampened industry gets a boost. Changes in tax are put in place to stimulate investment. The first steps of untrammelled subsidies giving way to real economic empowerment have been undertaken. Say hello to government as facilitator -rather than provider -of enterprise and growth

Mar 01 2015 : The Economic Times (Mumbai)
KEEP THE CHANGE
C RANGARAJAN FORMER GOVERNOR, RBI


A BEGINNING Dampened industry gets a boost. Changes in tax are put in place to stimulate investment. The first steps of untrammelled subsidies giving way to real economic empowerment have been undertaken. Say hello to government as facilitator -rather than provider -of enterprise and growth

Fiscal Consolidation Will Need Another Look

The Budget has attractive features, including measures to boost investment. Now the Modi govt must stick to this road map

The new government presented its first full-f ledged Budget on Saturday. The Budget has several features to stimulate investment, particularly in the area of infrastructure. While Finance Minister Arun Jaitley stuck to his commitment to contain fiscal deficit at 4.1% of GDP in the current year, he has extended the period over which the fiscal deficit will be brought down to the mandated 3% of GDP.

For the year 2015-16, the fiscal deficit is set at 3.9% against the earlier announced target of 3.6%. The budgeted deficit for next year will only be 0.2% less than in the current year.Significantly, the reduction in the revenue deficit is only 0.1%. Revenue deficit for the coming year continues to remain high at 2.8% of GDP.

While Jaitley has reiterated the government's commitment to fiscal consolidation, the smaller reduction in fiscal deficit is bit of a disappointment. The reduction in fiscal space occurs always in the year after the presentation of the Finance Commission's recommendations. Taking all transfers together, the reduction in space is only between 1-2 % of the divisible pool. One can only hope that the present road map will not undergo further changes.

Even to ensure that the fiscal deficit remains at the budgeted level, the revenue projections must hold good. In the current year, the revised estimates show a significant shortfall from the Budget estimates.The Budget projects a tax revenue growth of 15.8% over the revised estimates against a growth of 9.9% in the current year. With nominal income growing at around 11.5%, this is going to be a difficult task. The required tax buoyancy is 1.37. If the growth rate falls below 8%, the task will be rendered even more difficult.

The tax changes to stimulate investment are well-designed. As far as infrastructure is concerned, there is a clear recognition that government will have to play a bigger role. The proposed National Investment and Infrastructure Fund is meant to help infrastructure companies. In fact, in this context, it is worth considering whether we should revive the idea of setting up financial institutions focused exclusively on providing longterm capital resources to industries. Rate changes on the direct tax side are minimal, particularly as far as individuals are concerned. Some incentives for savings could have been thought of. On corporate tax, the reduction in the rate must be accompanied by reductions in exemptions. This has been talked about for a long time. But reducing exemptions has always been found to be difficult. On the indirect tax side, adjustments in Customs duties to prevent inverted duty structure are again a welcome measure.The increase in service tax is also appropriate as it is a prelude to the introduction of GST (Goods and Services Tax).

There are several measures to monetise gold. In fact, a reasonable rate of return on financial assets, primarily bank deposits, will by itself act as a disincentive to hold gold as an `asset'.

The expenditure programmes of the government have been laid out in detail. Several measures are a continuation of existing policy. As regards subsidies, it should have been possible to reduce them even further, given the recent reduction in oil prices. A modified system, which will result in reduction in fertiliser subsidies, is very much needed.

The Budget, as it was presented yesterday, has many attractive features.Several measures have been introduced to stimulate investment. There is an emphasis on increased social spending and creating additional social safety nets.

But much depends on the economy growing at 8% and tax revenues increasing at 15.8%. In the last few years, revenues have always fallen short of Budget estimates. The proposed reduction in fiscal deficit is below what it had been indicated earlier.

The revenue deficit continues to remain high. Growth with stability requires even stronger action on the fiscal consolidation front.










CLIMATE CHANGED   TRANSFORMATIVE Finance Minister Arun Jaitley's first `real' Budget has broken the earlier narrative. Whether this break from tradition will lead to achhe din for some, or to growth that will become genuinely inclusive, is something that will be played out over the year. But the blueprint is of change, and India is set on a journey

Mar 01 2015 : The Economic Times (Mumbai)
CLIMATE CHANGED


TRANSFORMATIVE Finance Minister Arun Jaitley's first `real' Budget has broken the earlier narrative. Whether this break from tradition will lead to achhe din for some, or to growth that will become genuinely inclusive, is something that will be played out over the year. But the blueprint is of change, and India is set on a journey
A Recipe that will Transform the Country

This Budget isn't just about fixing problems.

It also changes the context to find the solutions

With this Budget, finance minister Arun Jaitley has dexterously reinforced the government's commitment to transform the nation by rejuvenating its existing fabric: bringing in ease of conducting business, transparency in policies and stability in the tax regime.

At the same time, the Budget also supports new initiatives that encompass incubation facilities for start-ups, technology-led innovations for f lagship programmes such as `Make in India' and `Innovate in India', along with purposeful programmes like the universal social security system and the anti-inflation monetary policy framework to tackle India's challenges. Underlying this agenda is a strong foundation of fiscal discipline and a clear commitment to lowering the fiscal deficit to 3% in three years.

The emphasis on accelerating infrastructure development and simplifying policies for public-private partnership (PPP) will boost investor confidence. Implementation of the goods and services tax (GST), rationalisation of corporate tax and infusion of greater predictability into the tax regime can catalyse corporate investment and attract foreign business.

The Budget's zeal to curb black money is a big step towards restoring confidence in ethical business in the country. This business in the country. This could also go a long way in enhancing the image of India across the world.

The Budget clearly supports new and innovative ways for the country to accelerate its growth journey. The pro posal to work towards creat ing a universal social secu rity system for all Indians, and support for all aspects of start-up businesses and self-employment activities -particularly in technology-driven areas -are two great examples.

The move to reduce withholding tax on royalty and fees for technical services -from 25% to 10% -is another great enabler of innovation, as it serves to make investments in cutting-edge technology affordable for enterprises.

But what makes this Budget exercise truly laudable is the manner in which it takes into account the need to not just `fix problems' with solutions but to also change the very context in which the country seeks to find the solutions to its challenges.

One way in which the Budget hopes to achieve this is through its focus on education and initiatives to re-skill India's youth and enhance their employability. Support for pension schemes for the masses and health insurance for the underprivileged further demonstrate India's commitment to inclusive growth.

And it is this focus on changing the invisible context that will help bring in the more visible, more tangible positive changes we all hope to see in the year ahead. The world will watch -with great hope and anticipation -the execution of these policies that will help realise the aspirations of this Budget.

Giveaways for the Rich, and Cutbacks for the Poor

Unwarranted claims cannot elide the fact that the vast majority of Indians has been cruelly ignored

After starting with the jibe, "We inherited a sentiment of doomand gloom," the finance minister quickly claimed that "we have turned around the economy dramatically, restoring macro-stability and creating the conditions for sustainable poverty elimination, job creation and durable double-digit economic growth."

Neither the jibe nor the claim was warranted.

Government has acknowledged the data on growth put out by its Central Statistics Office.That means that GDP growth in 2013-14 was 6.9% -far from the picture of doom and gloom painted by the FM. Besides, if GDP growth improved from 6.9% to 7.4% in 2014-15, that is also a far cry from the claim that "we have turned around the economy dramatically".

In fairness, Arun Jaitley should have acknowledged the work done by the previous government and the stable economic situation that his government inherited, and then proceeded to recall the work done by his government since May 2014. There was no justification at all to depart from the fiscal consolidation path announced by the UPA government and adopted by the NDA government. Just two weeks ago, Jaitley reiterated his commitment to fiscal consolidation. In more than one place, the Economic Survey released on February 27 reiterated this commitment. For reasons that are not clear to me, the target of 3% to be achieved in 2016-17 has been set back by a year.

Government has claimed that it has stretched the fiscal deficit from 3.6% to 3.9% in 2015-16 because it needs the additional funds to increase public investment and to provide for the likely burden of the implementation of the Seventh Pay Commission and GST. This claim is suspect. 0.3% of GDP will mean an additional borrowing of `37,500 crore.

I looked into the numbers to see how the sum of `37,500 crore has been put to use. I found that Total Expenditure is projected to increase from `16,81,158 crore in RE 2014-15 to `17,77,477 crore in BE 2015-16. That is to be expected. However, the increase should have been reflected as increase in Plan Expenditure as well. Shockingly, Plan Expenditure is projected to decrease from `4,67,934 crore in RE 2014-15 to `4,65,277 crore in BE 2015-16. It appears to me that the additional borrowing of `37,500 crore will go entirely into increased Non-Plan Expenditure. The Budget speech has shown great concern for the corporates and the income-tax payers (3.5 crore). Given the BJP's leanings, that is understandable. What is worrying is that the vast majority of the people have been cruelly ignored. It is the majority -which does not fall under the category of corporate tax or incometax payers -which looks to the government for succour and relief. It is for this vast majority that social welfare programmes and schemes are devised and funds must be allocated.

What do we find in the Budget documents?
Allocations have been cut for crucial schemes compared to even the Revised Estimates of 2014-15. For example, under Scheduled Castes Sub Plan, the numbers (in crore) are `50,548 (BE 2014-215), `33,638 (RE 2014-15) and `30,850 (BE 2015-16). Similarly, under Tribal Sub Plan, the three corresponding numbers (in crore) are `32,386 (BE), n `20,535 (RE) and `19,979 (BE). There are similar s reductions for drinking water and sanitation, s health and family welfare, the Pradhan Mantri e Gram Sadak Yojana, the Prime Minister's y Employment Generation Programme, l Integrated Child Development Services, multi-sectoral development programmes for r minorities, culture, Project Tiger and so on.y These `cuts' are cruel and unjustified.s It is clear that the Budget -and the govern ment -leans in favour of the corporates. Few ? countries have corporate tax rates lower than s 30%. According to the finance minister, the efifective rate is 23%. He has promised them a 1% r reduction every year beginning 2016-17.d That is a `relief' of `20,000 crore every year (`80,000 crore in the fourth year) over four 8 years! Income-tax payers have got the benefit E of higher deductions. It is the non-income-tax E payer who has got the short end of the stick in r the form of higher excise duty and higher sere vice tax. I think the government's bias is clear.s Now, we must look to a vigorous and spirited ), debate in Parliament.

Good for India Inc, Even Better for Fisc

At last, a commitment to ease `doing business' along with a willingness to undertake fiscal discipline

Arun Jaitley has delivered with a path-breaking reformist effort. This continues the approach taken in his first Budget and maintains an emphasis on long-term planning. We saw the development and investment focus in the railway budget two days ago, and see the same goal orientation in the Union Budget. The overall themes are a commitment to fiscal discipline, measures to facilitate ease of doing business and, thereby, job creation, and a determined approach to simplify taxation.

Despite a tight fiscal space, the path of fiscal consolidation has been continued. While a benign external environment has no doubt played its part in the current fiscal, the government has shown a willingness to balance the fiscal discipline. One hopes that the fiscal consolidation path will be adhered to and met in the extended time frame. There is a concerted effort to improve the ease of doing business and to boost investment through support for corporates, infrastructure, small business and agri business.Many of the taxation proposals are geared towards simplification.

A reduction in the corporate tax rate, suitably balanced with the aim of rationalisation and removal of exemptions, and simplification by replacing wealth tax with a surcharge are commendable. Reducing the complexity of compli ance and a plethora of exemp tions have the potential to avoid disputes and will allow the government and citizens to focus on more productive use of their energy.

The proposed Mudra Bank and unified national agricul tural market can be expected to aid the growth and develop ment of SMEs and agri-based industries. This has been supported by measures to increase availability of finance, including by easing external flows, tightening evasion and an innovative approach to unlock physical savings and deploy them for productive investment.

The focus on development continues with Plan expenditure, higher expenditure on investment and through expanding and easing financing avenues to fund infrastructure projects. The proposed public debt management office will streamline the government's borrowing programme and will be watched.

For individual taxpayers and underprivileged sections of society, there is a vision on welfare and social development that is not delivered through subsidies alone. It aims to maximise impact of subsidies by curbing leakages where the Jan Dhan account platform will play a critical role. There is a focus on expanding the coverage of insurance and pension, and this is supported by the hike in individual exemption limits linked to an encouragement for creating long-term healthcare and social safety nets.

In summary, the focus on presenting a stable and predictable environment is clear. There is also a concerted effort to improve administration, encourage investments and enhance quality of life through a long-term investment and development-led approach.


















Tax Regime Gets Closer to GST

Mar 01 2015 : The Economic Times (Mumbai)
IN FOCUS - Tax Regime Gets Closer to GST
Deepshikha Sikarwar


THE BUDGET lays the ground for the new levy that will replace multiple central and states taxes as Finance Minister Arun Jaitley reiterates his promise for rolling out GST from April 1, 2016
Finance Minister Arun Jaitley may have avoided giving definite milestone for imple mentation of various components of goods and services tax (GST), but his Budget for 2015-16 clearly laid the ground for the new levy that will replace multiple central and states taxes.

Jaitley also reiterated his promise for rolling out GST from April 1, 2016, ending any further doubts about the timelines for this ambitious tax reform.

Increase in service tax rate, subsuming education cess with excise duty and pruning items on the exempted list of items are among the important steps in the progression towards GST.

Though a significant increase in service tax to 14% --16% if 2% Swachh Bharat cess is imposed on all services -from 12% may pinch the aam aadmi in the immediate term, it prepares him for higher incidence of tax on services under the GST regime. Going by the increase in service tax rate, the case for government opting for a high 16% GST rate (8% for states and 8% for the centre) or even higher has strengthened.

Businesses would also face some pain in the intervening period until the GST is implemented due to divergence in excise duty and service tax rates as it could lead to a pile of input tax credit. But, this pain may short-lived, for a year, as the government has promised to launch GST by April next year.

GST seeks to subsume a plethora of state-level and central taxes into one and thereby reduce effective taxation of goods and also create a seamless national market in the country. It was to be rolled out starting April 1, 2010, but got delayed as some states were reluctant to give assent to the plan for fear of losing tax revenue. The Narendra Modi-led NDA government has tabled a constitutional amendment bill in Parliament to pave the way for GST.

While raising the tax rate, the government has also opted for a cleanup of exemptions, not just in service tax but also in excise duty. The negative or exempted list has been pruned and exemptions cut in line with the thinking that the base of services taxation needs to be widened.

A similar philosophy has been adopted in excise duty, where rationalisation has been focused on reducing exemptions as well as ad dressing the issue of inverted duty structure. Steps have been taken to incentivise manufacturing. Special additional duty has been exempted for most electronics goods, and halved to 2% for a number of chemical products in line with the Make in India phi losophy. In line with making India an easier place to do business, the Budget has unveiled a number of facilitation measures such as acceptance of digital invoices and quick registration.

Tax experts term the Budget as a mixed bag and seek more clarity on timelines for implementation of GST."On the indirect taxes front, the Budget proposals are a mixed bag. Proposals towards widening of the tax base by pruning exemptions, abolition of the education cess and rationalisation of the tax rates take the current tax regime a step closer to GST," said R Muralidharan, senior director at Deloitte in India .

Govt Services in Tax Net

New items could figure in the govern ment's service tax list such as the auc tion of spectrum and mining rights or the leasing of government land and buildings as the budget has substantially pruned the negative list, which details those areas that are exempt.

But the Centre could still notify them as exempted government services after the passage of the finance bill. The budget move is in line with the proposed goods and services tax regime that hinges on low rates but a wide base.

The finance bill seeks to incorporate definitions of "government" and "service" and make an enabling provision to exclude all services provided by the government or local authorities to a business entity from the negative list.

Spectrum sales and coal auctions have yielded a windfall for the Centre and the states, respectively. The government could generate more money from such exercises by imposing service tax on auctions going forward since the right to use mines and spectrum constitute part of services offered by government.

Tax experts sought clarity on the amendment as it could have broad impact. "Expansion of service tax to include to any government services provided to business entities as against only support services could have wide ramifications and amount collected through spectrum and coal block allocation could also be subjected to service tax," said Pratik Jain, partner, KPMG.








GAAR on Hold for 2 Years, DTC Abandoned

Mar 01 2015 : The Economic Times (Mumbai)
GAAR on Hold for 2 Years, DTC Abandoned
Vikas Dhoot
New Delhi


SENSIBLE MOVE DTC won't be pursued as most of its ideas incorporated in I-T Act
Staying true to Prime Minister Narendra Modi's commitment to global investors of fostering a stable and predictable tax regime to replace the era of tax terrorism unleashed by the previous UPA government, finance minister Arun Jaitley said the General Anti-Avoidance Rules (GAAR) will be deferred for two more years and investments made till March 2017 will be exempted when they are implemented.

Laying another major uncertainty to rest for taxpayers, the finance minister said the Direct Taxes Code, in the making for many years, won't be pursued any further as most of its ideas have been incorporated in the Income Tax Act.

"There is no great merit in going ahead with the Direct Tax Code as it exists today," he said, citing the well-evolved jurisprudence on existing income tax laws.

The finance minister hinted that General Anti-Avoidance Rules wasn't desirable at a time when reviving the investment cycle is critical. "There are certain contentious issues relating to GAAR which need to be resolved," the minister said, declaring that it will only apply `prospectively' from April 1, 2017. GAAR is aimed at curbing tax avoidance.

Industry experts appreciated the moves as sensible. Siemens' managing director and CEO Sunil Mathur said the move to defer GAAR and reduce corporate taxes will boost industry confidence.

"Investors now have time to prepare themselves for General Anti Avoidance Rules. Though we hoped for it to be postponed by five years, this is acceptable if the government cleans up tax administration in the meanwhile," said Daksha Baxi, executive director at law firm Khaitan & Co.